Saturday, June 11, 2011

The Report

The Report: A Novel
The Report: A Novel
by Jessica Francis Kane, Greywolf Press, August 2010




  ...a small gem that is both educational and moving

This is a fictionalized telling of a true story – the death of 173 Londoners on March 3, 1943 and its aftermath. In entering the Bethnal Green Tube station to shelter from a German air raid people were trampled when for unknown reasons the crowd pushed forward and crushed and suffocated many of them. The government asks a respected London magistrate, Laurence Dunne to investigate the tragedy and write a report. He does so in three weeks, interviewing over 80 witnesses, local politicians, engineers and others. The story is told primarily through the eyes of 8 year old Tilly, her mother Ada, Warden Low the shelter manager, Reverend Mc Neely the pastor, and several others. As the thirtieth anniversary of the tragedy approaches, Paul Barber works with the now retired Dunne to film a documentary of the event. Barber was orphaned as an infant when he was saved but his mother was not.

I read this book straight through and couldn’t put it down or get it out of my head. It was good on so many levels. The writing is clear, concise and wonderfully descriptive – there are no wasted words here – kudos to the author and her editor! An example

           …talking to him was like talking to any young person about the war years; they spoke from a background of black-and-white pictures, while your memories were very much in color. They asked about the rationing, while you saw coupons. They spoke about the public morale, when what you remembered were the faces. Try as they might, they only heard a chord or two, while the whole symphony still roared in your head.

The research is impressive. The details of life in war time London enrich the story – there were no weather reports for Londoners throughout the war, sewing circles making topographical maps of German landscapes for the RAF to cite two examples that were new to me. The author gives an authentic feel to the Bethnal Green community and their feelings after this event.

Dunne wants to avoid scapegoating one person or one group so he makes some interesting decisions as he completes his report. The questions that the author raises as Dunne finishes his report are universal and have applicability far beyond this time period. In times of war are decisions that support civilian morale justifiable? Do all tragedies have a responsible party? Is it even possible to determine exact circumstances when witnesses have conflicting views? Do people act differently in a crowd than when alone?

In a story that could easily have been melodramatic and given to sentimentality the author has delivered a small gem that is both educational and moving. A great read!

I read a copy of this book borrowed from The Free Library of Philadelphia

5 comments:

reviewsbylola said...

I had not heard of the Bethnal Green disaster until this book came out, so I was glad to learn about an important piece of civilian history during WWII while also reading some great fiction!

Zibilee said...

I had also not heard of this disaster, but it sounds like the book does it's due diligence and gets the story from all sorts of perspectives. This sounds like an interesting book and like one I wouldn't mind reading. Great review, Kathy!

Elizabeth said...

I have never heard of this.

Stopping by from Cym's Book Party.

I am having a Father's Day giveaway on my blog if you would like to stop by.

http://silversolara.blogspot.com/2011/06/fathers-day-giveaway-from-little-brown.html

Hope you can visit.

Elizabeth

Julie @ Knitting and Sundries said...

What an interesting premise! I love the quote you used, and the reason I love historical fiction is that with most, you learn something that you didn't know about before.

Carole said...

Great review.

I didn't enjoy this book quite as much as you did. While I really enjoyed the writing and the story, I had a hard time connecting with any of the characters. The author seemed to intentionally keep them at arms length from us. It was a good "read", I just never felt a "part of it" (if that makes sense.)

But you quoted one of my very favorite paragraphs in the book! And the story WAS memorable, and it very well may be that I will decide later that this book had a bigger impact on me than what I feel today (I just finished reading it yesterday).

So I would recommend it, I just wouldn't give it 5 stars.